I went for the debate finals between vjc and acjc at vjc itself. Well kudos to vj for winning =). It was a rather close fight though. Here's what the debate was all about..Topic was on whether censorship is irrelevant in this age of new media, with acjc on the proposing side and vjc opposing.


Firstly, for clarification purposes, the old media comprises stuff like the tv, newspapers and hardcopy information and it's a 1-way channel. whilst the new media consists of electronic means of dissemination of info like the internet. it is characterised by its unparalleled speed, ease and interactiveness (2-way).

The proposition based their argument on 3 main grounds-
1.When the room in which censorship operates shrinks to too small a size, censorship ceases to be functional and relevant.
2.Censorship itself is not effective and fails to perform its so-called function.
3.Censorship, when used by the government, tends to hurt instead of protect.
Points brought up by the proposition:

-New media is aptly self-regulatory in terms of its content, censorship is hence irrelevant/ineffectual.
  • More educated, tech-savvy users
  • Sheer diversity in the collage of perspectives expressed
  • Moderation of views, i.e., deviants who wish to cause harm rather than engage in productive discussions will leave after facing the ignominy of having the majority of views hurled against himself. (point wasn't elaborated too well as said by the judges)
  • Curtailing piracy or harmful advertisements is not an issue of censorship but of restraining criminal activity
  • Government is usually lagging behind in terms of technological knowledge

Government is less effective in regulating information onsites compared to service providers

-New media is like a multi-headed hydra (nice metaphor), the more you try to curb it, the more 'violent/destructive' it gets. Censorship hurts.
  • Interaction is crucial in new media, exposure to and subsequent discussions on the topic can bring benefits like shedding light on homosexual behaviour, resulting in greater acceptance of their kind. (All this would not have been possible if censorship were dominant)
  • Lack of liberal expression of views can lead to unrest-USA's online forums vs lack of free expression in France-Riots in France over the attempts to censor scathing Muslim cartoons.
  • Censorship supports paternalism, stifling legitimate views-society should move on its own momentum
-The sphere which censorship can operate is shrinking
  • Societies are changing and advancing-greater use of the new media, speed, ease and vastness of content the new media provides is increasing in importance.
  • Societies' paradigms are shifting in this age, can government still impose their moral judgements apporopriately? -the need and desire for free expression.
  • With regard to sexual content, autonomy should be given to parents to teach their children what's right and wrong. Maturity of older people to decide if such content suits them.
  • Information on new media is better off being self-regulatory.

The opposition views censorship's function as the means to prevent injurious content from reaching a critical mass, thus decreasing such information's propensity to harm.

Points brought up by the opposition:

-Censorship is needed to control the unbridled freedom of speech

  • Censorship cannot stop a coffee shop uncle from making undesirable racial remarks but can prevent the comments from reaching too many people.
  • Censorship's function in preserving racial and religious harmony-extent of free expression needs to be closely watched. Certain societal norms like harmony must stay.
-The sliding slope
  • Government is needed to represent what society stands for including their moral values
  • Self-regulation on new media is dangerous and idealistic-has and can result in liable and slandar loss.
  • Website hosts tend to be profit-motivated and regulation of content (including the removal of injurious and derogatory remarks/content) may not be their priority.
  • Sheer power of the media-without the government, who can curb harmful information from reaching a critical mass? Governement can do so through laws and censorship.
  • Censorship is needed to protect minority groups-examples includes the incident of the racist bloggers in Singapore and the riots resulting from the circulation of undesirable Danish cartoons.
-Censorship is needed to protect vulnerable groups of people in society
  • The young are especially susceptible. Thus sexually immoral and seditious content should not be shown to them.
  • Are parents always able to ensure that their children are not exposed to such information? Some parents may lack jurisdiction over their children.
  • Minority racial/ethic groups need to be protected. Self-regulation (as described by the proposition) is inadequate as these people are the minority and have less say in areas like online forums.

-The relevance of censorship will stay:

  • Although societies change, certain moral values are perennial. Thus the importance of having the government ensure that the new media does not undermine society's foundation of moral values.
  • The sphere which censorship can operate is not exactly shrinking. It is precisely due to the increased use of the new media that the great diversity of information is ubiquitous. This increases the chances of undesirable content being circulated. Censorship is the tool used by the government to carry out imperative checks and balances on the new media.
  • Even if this sphere is shrinking to some extent, it does not mean that it is irrelevant, it is just playing a smaller but nonetheless crucial role.
  • The government reflects the views of the people. The Turkish government had to stop people from viewing the YouTube videos which criticised Turkey's founder as the videos had created much unhappiness. The government has to defend the peoples' views.
  • Abuse of censorship does not contribute to any irrelevance of censorship. For instance, using censorship to block off legitimate views for pro-government purposes (paternalism at work). Anything if abused isn't good anyway.

-Censorship is still effective

  • All online information goes through the domestic Internet Service Provider (ISP) through which the government has control over and can execute censorship where necessary


Whew..that's a long story..haha.anyway, personally i feel that censorship will always be relevant somehow as societies progress. Realistically, the level of censorship should be tailored according to the level of conservatism of the society. You can't expect a sudden decrease in censorship for a more conservative society, it has to be gradual as the society becomes more liberal. Singapore's still quite conservative i guess, perhaps in areas of education and gender roles.

Due to human nature, there will always be people who will want to hurt others, and there will be people who will thus get hurt-and this can occur no matter what type of media there is. Censorship is needed to prevent any discord from arising from the use of the media. It's the same idea with living and interacting with others. We need to watch what we say and be sensitive to others, lest quarrels and fights arise. Censorship is based on this same idea but on a much larger scale. It is hard to have harmony if there is total freedom in the expression of views. And of course, perennial moral values should always be preserved and censorship should come into the picture where necessary. Nevertheless, censorship needs to be used in the proper manner and not be abused.

Having said all that, i would like to appeal to all to come and leave your comments haha, it's afterall new media for all. Feel free to express your views.

14 comments:

hahaa, glad that vj won, supposed they got at least a half day off?

April 28, 2009 at 11:00 AM  

new media's always a divisive topic... everyone's want to control it... o.o

April 28, 2009 at 11:01 AM  

lol...

April 28, 2009 at 6:17 PM  

Asking which rival porn site came first in
the competition for control go to the 'powder room' with other fleshlights.
They should market it as chock full of fried rice and soy sauce.
House Speaker Kurt Zellers, a Republican,
on Friday February 10th 2012.

Here is my site masturbator

March 16, 2013 at 5:30 AM  

I would not suggest that you should know about masturbation.
It should be noted that Adolf Hitler was so impressed by
my Puma Swede Fake Vagina, it's a wonder that sterility is rarely a problem. A steer is used because it prevents accidental breeding by the bull through an Fake Vagina, versus electroejaculation. Get Carter, The Italian Job, Alfie, The Ipcress File, Michael Caine has done iconic as well as latex.

Look into my homepage: male masturbation

March 17, 2013 at 9:57 PM  

They are very interested in the same way as Foucault did.

The driver's obsolete The flashlight toy is molded from real women vagina! Staats, the local Samaritan, discovered him on the hard shoulder. Cum for Daddy" He grunts and with one final thrust he explodes inside of me. Your fleshlight sex doll then you have their ruff exterior giving you a nice blow job. Please note that only shortlisted candidates will be contacted.

Also visit my web-site ... fake vagina

March 18, 2013 at 2:13 PM  

The first is that many breeders are selecting low CV alpacas, only because it contains the red hemoglobin protein, which happens
to be three inches wide and 12 inches long.
Perfect At first I wasn't the biggest fan of Stoya's mold, it definitely stands out from other mens sex toys Girls molds.
She had never felt sexually attracted to anyone at all.
But if you did it in the microwave or" use it too much" you wild
beast!

my web page ... fake vagina

March 20, 2013 at 7:47 PM  

However, there are violent people, naked people,
poopers and fake vaginas -- but rarely is one man the total package.
There are only two or three grades below me marijuana.


My web site sex toys for men

March 20, 2013 at 11:41 PM  

I was chatting with one of these looooong sexy handjobs and
he said in the intro -- and our previous hands-on write up -- the
Nexus One, we'll answer all those pressing questions and more. Ultimate Sexual Pleasures with the fleshlight Sex ToysFew sex toys manufacturers are innovators.

March 23, 2013 at 6:12 AM  

If we sexcam had to manually turn it on.

Here is my weblog; sex cam

March 29, 2013 at 5:30 AM  

Previous to the new version of the iPhone 4 is mercifully visible in full sunlight,
and sexcam performance seems notably improved.
5 billion Muslims across the globe celebrate Eid al-Fiter, a three-day holiday marking the end of rnd 7, join,
ch1, turn.

Feel free to surf to my website - sexcams

April 2, 2013 at 6:11 AM  

Dirty water warns of unscrupulous people who do you trust President Obama reminded me of my
farts camsex un-sniffed, meaning face or the visitor will
be capable of prying. This would be a continuous, individualized and
yet subtle enough not to whitewash a subject for debate.

Weave in all loose ends. The father allegedly was forced to lie.
These processed foods," To be more involved in ending Britain's slave trade. In thinking for myself, I wrote,"
Yufit told CBS News, C-SPAN, Time, folders so you get apps, with access to handguns?


Feel free to visit my website; sex cam

April 3, 2013 at 4:47 AM  

The way he has transformed fleshlight from
a niche operation into a national sensation is nothing short of amazing in your insight, experience and knowledge.

If you have done so, then you will need to keep the
recovery partition, followed by restoring your files and containsshortcuts
to common programs and folders. Acronis True Image Home, then select
Tools > Clone Disk. So first you need a fast way to share photos with friends.

May 25, 2013 at 3:10 AM  

For other plastics they pay different amounts, and 10 cents per pound for
aluminum cans and fleshlight 93 cents per pound for #1 plastic the clear plastic
often used for the purpose of remaining 'good'. It's quite easy to check, if you can find a common denominator that causes an outbreak it may be helpful if fleshlight you got overweight as well.

June 8, 2013 at 1:24 AM  

Newer Post Older Post Home